מסמך פטנט עם סימן X אדום ומאזני צדק ברקע, המדגים ביטול פטנט

Revocation of a Patent

Revocation of a patent is a proceeding that takes place after the grant of a patent. In it, another person requests to revoke the patent. In other words, the requesting party argues that the Patent Office should not have granted the patent. Therefore, he asks to revoke the monopoly of the owner of the invention. He also asks to revoke the legal right called a patent.

Filing such a request requires the payment of a fee. The Registrar of Patents’ tribunal then hears the request. The Registrar will decide between the parties. These are the patent owner and the party requesting the revocation. In the end, the Registrar will decide whether or not to revoke the patent.

A party may appeal the Registrar’s decision as of right. To do so, he files an application to the District Court. In addition, a party may appeal the decision of the District Court to the Supreme Court. However, this further appeal requires leave.

Who May File for Revocation of a Patent? When? And on What Grounds?

Section 73B of the Patents Law states: “The Registrar may, at the request of any person who is not the owner of the patent, revoke a patent if he found that there is a ground on which the grant of the patent could have been opposed; the laws of prescription shall not apply to a request for revocation under this section.” (emphasis not in the original).

Who may file for revocation of a patent? “… any person…”

Grounds for Revocation of a Patent

What are the grounds?  “a ground on which the grant of the patent could have been opposed”

These are the reasons for which a person can oppose the grant of a patent:

“There is a reason on account of which the Registrar would have been authorized to refuse the acceptance of the patent application”. This means that the examiner erred. He had no authority to approve the grant of a patent. In other words, according to the requesting party, the applicant did not meet the Patents Law and Regulations.

In other words, a person can request revocation if the patent does not meet the Patents Law. The Patents Law states in Section 3 what a patentable invention is. An applicant must meet this definition. He must also meet the other conditions of the law. The definition reads: “An invention, whether a product or a process in any field of technology, which is new, useful, can be applied industrially and involves an inventive step – is a patentable invention.” (emphasis not in the original).

“The invention is not patentable under Section 4(2)”, i.e. “4. An invention is considered to be new if it has not been published, whether in Israel or abroad, before the application date…” “(2) by way of exploitation or display, so that a person skilled in the art can carry it out according to the details that became known in this way.”

“The opponent, and not the applicant, is the owner of the invention.” In other words, someone else filed the invention. Yet it is not his invention.

When can a person file a request for revocation of a patent? At any time: “… the laws of prescription shall not apply…”

Parallel Proceedings Before the Registrar and the Court

A Race of Jurisdictions in a Request for Revocation of a Patent between the Registrar of Patents and the Court

This proceeding involves a kind of race of jurisdictions between the Registrar of Patents and the court. Therefore, the manner and timing of a warning letter matter greatly. This is true, for example, of a warning letter before a patent infringement claim.

Section 74 of the Patents Law states: “Where a request for deletion under Chapter D or a request for revocation under Chapter D or under this Chapter was submitted to the Registrar while a proceeding for the infringement of that patent or its revocation is pending in court, the Registrar shall not hear it except with the permission of the court.” In other words, a patent owner may have already filed an infringement claim. In that case, the Registrar will not hear the revocation request. He will hear it only if the court grants permission.

Moreover, the law states: “Where proceedings were opened in court for the infringement of a patent after a request for its revocation or deletion was submitted to the Registrar, the Registrar shall continue to hear the request, unless the court has given a different instruction in this matter.”

In other words, a person may send a warning letter before filing a patent infringement claim. The alleged infringer may then file a revocation request. He does so before the patent owner files the infringement claim against him. In that case, the Registrar of Patents will hear the request. The exception is when the court has instructed otherwise.

Risks and Legal Strategy

However, it is important to remember that this step also carries a legal and financial risk. The risk applies to a party who exploits the invention and files for revocation. If his request fails, he may also face a cause of action for damages caused by it. As a result, the costs of the legal proceedings and the damages against him will increase.

Our firm handles proceedings of filing a request for revocation of a patent. We also defend clients against such requests. In this proceeding, the Registrar of Patents will hear the case before the Registrar of Patents’ tribunal.

It is worth consulting with us regarding the legal strategy. This helps you avoid actions that are not beneficial. In some cases, such actions are even harmful.

The above information is partial and incomplete. Please consult an attorney and patent attorney in each case individually. For more details, call +972-3-9711013.

Contact us
for professional guidance

Fill in your details and we will get back to you shortly

Basic questions before registering your patent

Contact us to advance the protection of your rights