Illustration for an article on freedom to operate: a globe with a magnifying glass and a shield with a check mark

Freedom to Operate: What an FTO Search Answers

Freedom to operate is the question of whether you can make, use or sell a specific product or process in a specific country without infringing patent rights that someone else holds there. An FTO search looks for patents and pending applications that are still in force and may cover what you plan to do. It answers a different question from “can I get a patent?”, and the answer is always tied to a product, a country and a point in time.

Freedom to operate vs patentability

These two searches are often confused, partly because both involve reading patents. However, they start from opposite directions. WIPO describes a patentability search as one that identifies patents and non-patent literature that may affect the patentability of an invention, ideally done before the application is written and filed. A freedom-to-operate search, by contrast, identifies in-force patents or applications that may cover a proposed product or process.

Patentability search Freedom to operate search
Question Is my invention new and inventive? Does my product fall within someone else’s rights?
What counts Any earlier publication, anywhere, including expired patents and articles Only patents and applications still in force, or that may still be granted
What is compared Your invention against prior art Your product against other parties’ claims
Geography Publications worldwide matter Only the countries where you will make, use or sell
Typical timing Before drafting a patent application Before launch, manufacture or investment

The practical consequence is important. Owning a patent does not by itself give you the right to sell your product. Your patent may cover an improvement, while an earlier patent held by someone else still covers the basic platform. A favorable patentability result says nothing about this.

Why FTO is country-specific

Patents are granted by national or regional offices. Even the PCT route, which allows one international application with legal effect in all PCT Contracting States, leaves grant to the national or regional offices in the national phase. Therefore an FTO search for Israel, the US and Germany is really three separate questions.

Timing rules also differ by country. In Israel, the patent term is generally 20 years from the application date. The Patents Law also allows limited extension orders for certain pharmaceutical and medical-device patents. In the US, the term generally ends 20 years from the US filing date, or from the earliest US or PCT application the patent specifically refers to under the relevant sections; foreign and provisional priority does not count toward the term. As a result, the same invention can be protected for different periods in different countries, and the expiry date has to be checked per patent.

A pending PCT application adds another layer. For most offices the national phase is due before the end of the 30th month from the priority date, and national laws may allow more time. Until that window closes, an international application may still enter the national phase, and later lead to granted patents, in countries where you plan to operate.

What an FTO search involves

WIPO notes that an FTO search is country or region specific and requires analysis of claims and legal status. In practice, the work usually follows these steps:

  1. Define the product precisely. List the technical features, components, materials and process steps of the version you will actually sell, not the general concept.
  2. Choose the countries. Include where you will manufacture, sell and import, and where key competitors hold rights.
  3. Search. Use patent databases such as WIPO PATENTSCOPE together with classification and keyword strategies, and look at both granted patents and published applications.
  4. Screen the results. Remove documents that are clearly irrelevant, expired or outside the target countries.
  5. Analyze the claims. The claims define the scope of protection, so the product is compared with the wording of the claims, not with the description or drawings alone.
  6. Check legal status. Confirm whether each patent is granted, pending, lapsed or expired. For example, an Israeli patent stays in force only if renewal fees are paid, with a six-month late-payment window. Status in one country says nothing about another.
  7. Report and decide. Rank the risks and consider the options for each relevant patent.

When to run a freedom to operate analysis

The value of an FTO analysis is highest before money is committed. Typical trigger points include:

  • Before launching a product in a new market.
  • Before ordering tooling or starting mass manufacture.
  • Before an investment round or acquisition, where investors may ask how patent risk was assessed.
  • Before signing a licensing or distribution agreement.
  • After a significant design change, since a new feature can bring new patents into play.

Running it too early can also waste effort, because the product may still change. A common approach is a lighter review during development and a fuller analysis once the design is close to final. For background on search tools, see the guide to searching patents with free tools such as Google Patents.

What an FTO opinion can and cannot guarantee

An FTO opinion is a reasoned risk assessment, not a guarantee. It has several built-in limits:

  • Unpublished applications. In Israel, applications open to public inspection 18 months from filing, or from the earliest priority date. Applications filed more recently may not be visible to any search.
  • Pending claims are not final. The claims of a pending application may change during examination, so today’s assessment of a pending case may need updating.
  • Interpretation. Claim scope is a matter of interpretation, and a court or office may read a claim differently from the analyst.
  • A snapshot in time. The opinion reflects the product, countries and patent records at the date of the search.

When a relevant patent is found, there are usually several options: redesign the product to avoid the claims, seek a license, challenge the patent through an available procedure, or plan the launch around its expiry. In Israel, for example, any person may oppose the grant of a patent within three months after publication of the acceptance. Choosing between these options is a commercial decision as much as a legal one, and it often ties into broader intellectual property and commercial support.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a freedom to operate search the same as a patent search?

No. A patentability search asks whether your invention is new. An FTO search asks whether your product falls within patents held by others in specific countries.

If I have my own patent, do I still need an FTO search?

Possibly. Your patent shows that your invention was granted protection, but it does not show that your product is free of other parties’ earlier claims.

Does an FTO search in Israel cover the US?

No. FTO is country-specific. Each country where you make, use or sell the product needs its own review of the patents and applications in force there.

Can an FTO opinion guarantee that I will not be sued?

No. It reduces uncertainty and documents a careful assessment, but unpublished applications, changes to pending claims and differences in interpretation mean some risk always remains.

Sources: WIPO PATENTSCOPE glossary definitions of FTO and patentability searches and the WIPO PCT FAQs. Israeli law references are to the Patents Law 5727-1967 (unofficial English translation on WIPO Lex; the Hebrew text controls).

This article is general information and does not replace advice on the specific case.

If you are preparing to launch, manufacture or raise funds, an initial conversation can help define which product, which countries and which level of FTO review fit your stage. You can reach the office at 03-9711013, without sending confidential technical details in advance.

Contact us
for professional guidance

Fill in your details and we will get back to you shortly

Basic questions before registering your patent

Contact us to advance the protection of your rights